The long awaited letter from the School Admission Board arrived today. Horror of Horrors, Ruby didn’t get into our first choice school! A few frantic phone calls and we find that Ruby is 0.002 miles too far away to make the cutoff. Great, we need to move a few yards down the road. Being so close does mean that Ruby is first on the waiting list, so if anyone who already has a place drops out, then we are up next (someone please move away).
In order to get Ruby into the school she already attends at Nursery, we will have to go to an appeal. Mucho hard work and heartache.
Now we are very lucky to live in an area where the vast majority of the primary schools are good, and most of them are under-subscribed. We just happen to live closest to one that has very few places (which is why we want her there – small class sizes and it is closest). It would not actually be a really major set-back to have Ruby go to our second choice school. It is still a good school.
This does not stop me being annoyed at the admissions policy however. Basically, it is designed to give the impression of choice, but does not actually deliver that choice in many cases. In Billingham, one can generally choose a school and get into it (with the exception of the one we picked through perversity). This is partly because the town has a lot of schools left over from when the town had a much younger demographic, but also partly because they are all pretty good. The good schools are everywhere, so there isn’t much competition for places. In places less fortunate, there is either stiff competition for the few good schools, or most schools are over subscribed. In these cases, you can ‘choose’ to go to what ever school you like, but in reality will go where the Authority sends you.
Any system must be better than this. A lot of forms get filled in, a lot of hopes get raised, and the child ends up where ever there is space regardless.
Much better I think to admit this up front and just inform parents which school they have been allocated (preferably before they begin any Nursery) and be done with it.
I’d really rather see schools specialise in certain areas then be allowed to select on the basis of their specialism, but I realise that is far too elitist for our modern “one size fits all” society, where giving a mediocre and general education to everyone is preferred to any form of selecting for aptitude.
Update 12/05 Just found out that one of the children who was accepted into our first choice school lives just two doors down the road from us but has been going to a private nursery! Boo and Hiss!